NEWS

Artistic freedom outweighs rights of luxury handbag manufacturer Hermés

Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main, Decision of September 19, 2023 – 2-06 O 532/23; 2-06 O 533/23

 Contents

Fashion label allowed to incorporate characteristic features of a luxury handbag

The Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main has ruled in a trademark dispute between the Berlin fashion label Namilia and luxury handbag manufacturer Hermés that the fashion label can adopt iconic features of the handbag in their creations. The court justified the decision by stating that engagement with a brand can be covered by artistic freedom.

Hermés objected to the performance at a fashion show

The fashion label Namilia presented fashion creations at a fashion show that were inspired by the luxury handbag from Hermés. These creations were promoted on the internet and social media. Hermés took legal action against the performances.

Artistic expression supersedes Hermés' property rights

The court ruled that these performances are covered by artistic freedom and that the “interest rooted in artistic freedom“ of the fashion label in the artistic expression of the fashion show outweighs Hermés’ property rights.

The court argued that the brand is not denigrated or diminished, but instead serves as a socially desired reference point for luxury goods. The association with the luxury handbag is only one part of the overall staging and does not constitute trademark infringement.

To the point

The decision emphasizes that engagement with a brand can be protected under artistic freedom. This ruling could have potential implications for future trademark disputes, particularly in the art and fashion industry, and could lead to further expansion of the protection of artistic freedom.

more News

Trademark Law

The Independent characteristic position of the Opposition Mark “COCO” in the challenged trademark “HiCoco”

CHANEL partially prevails – The Federal Patent Court in Germany (BPatG) rules that “HiCoco” cannot be claimed for perfume in Class 3.
Competition Law

No protection against imitation under unfair competition law for “Glück” (happiness)

Wird ein Produktname verwendet, der Emotionen hervorruft, wie „Glück“, dann ist dies ein Konzept, das über das Wettbewerbsrecht grundsätzlich nicht geschützt ist.
Copyright

Berlin Court of Appeal (KG) decides on the copyright permissibility of framing and the limit of Section 50 of the German Copyright Law (press privilege)

The framing of photos may be permissible under copyright law in the context of current events if this falls within the scope of Section 50 of the German Copyright Law (reporting on current events).

Karin Simon
Lawyer
Certified IP Lawyer

Susanne Graeser
Lawyer
Certified IP Lawyer

Uhlandstr. 2
80336 Munich
Germany

Phone +49 89 90 42 27 51-0
Fax +49 89 90 42 27 51-9

Karin Simon
Rechtsanwältin

Fachanwältin für
gewerblichen Rechtsschutz

Susanne Graeser
Rechtsanwältin

Fachanwältin für
gewerblichen Rechtsschutz

Uhlandstr. 2
D-80336 München

Tel. +49 89 90 42 27 51-0
Fax +49 89 90 42 27 51-9